Stage 4 · Learning to Listen
Segment 2 of 3 · about 14 minutes

Why Listening Comes First

Three ways of meditating, the spiral, and the seven practices you can choose from.

Part 3. Why Listening Comes First

3.1 What “listening” means here

The word is chosen on purpose. Listening is not forcing your mind to be blank. It is not suppression, and it is not willpower. It is giving your attention to one simple thing to do, gently, and coming back to it every time you drift.

Science gives the reason why this works. If the current evidence is right, attention is the brain’s volume knob. Whatever you attend to gets turned up and feels more real. Whatever you stop attending to gets turned down. When you keep your attention on one simple, present thing – such as a breath, a step, or a visual stimulus such as a circle – the story-making parts of the brain get less to work with, and they quiet down. You are not fighting thoughts. You are giving them less volume.

Several of the traditions describe this in their own words.

Teresa describes this kind of listening as setting talk aside. Rather than reasoning things through, the soul stays alert to whatever God is doing within it. She adds that this inner work is gentle and peaceful.

– Paraphrased from Teresa of Avila, The Interior Castle, Fourth Mansion, Chapter 3

“Concentration is the centering of consciousness evenly and rightly on a single object… Its function is to eliminate distraction.”

– Buddhaghosa, Buddhist master, The Path of Purification

“Sever connections with everything other than what is desired… Reflection is seeking, but remembrance is finding.”

– Abdullah al-Ansari, Sufi master, Stations of the Sufi Path

Teresa calls it listening. Buddhaghosa calls it anchoring. Al-Ansari calls it severing distractions so that remembrance becomes possible. Each describes the same movement. The attention is gathered. It drifts. It is returned. That returning, done without self-criticism and without bargaining, is the practice. Each return trains the capacity to stay.

The Paradox

Returning your attention is the practice, and it is a deliberate act. You notice you have drifted, let the drift go, and bring your attention gently back to the anchor. If you find yourself pushing, bracing, or driving your attention back, something else has taken over. That pushing is often the self quietly reasserting control, in the very place you are trying to loosen it. Treat it as one more drift: notice it, let it go, and return gently.

3.2 Three ways of meditating, and why the order matters

Part 2 described three kinds of meditation. The traditions that use all three generally teach them in the same order, and there are good reasons for that order. It is a safety argument as much as an effectiveness argument. (The authors of the 2021 paper place the three on one continuum. The training order is our own synthesis from the traditions.)

Kind

What it loosens

What must be steady first

What goes wrong if skipped

Focused attention

Scatter and the automatic drift into story.

Your daily behavior and your inner honesty (Stages 2 and 3).

Later practices collapse into mind-wandering or restless straining.

Open monitoring

The belief that your thoughts and feelings are you.

The ability to stay with one thing.

Watching without an anchor turns into rumination, analysis, or being flooded.

Letting-go

The split between the watcher and what is watched, the self and what is observed.

The ability to observe without reacting.

Bypassing, numbness, or a false “nothing matters” state.

Four reasons support this order.

  • You cannot let go of what you cannot see. Focused attention builds the part of you that can watch. Open monitoring then lets you see your self-model working as a process. Only after that does it make sense to loosen the split between watcher and watched.
  • Deliberate practice belongs at the beginning. Gathering attention is something you do on purpose at first: you notice the drift, let it go, and return gently. That deliberate work is honest work. The later practices cannot be done by deliberate doing without turning into gripping. The spiritual traditions say that what comes later is received, not made. So the deliberate kind comes first, and then the habit of making things happen has to be outgrown, not carried forward.
  • Safety. The researchers warn that changes in the sense of self, the sense of your own identity, can be distressing. It is our judgment, drawn from the traditions and from reports of difficult meditation experiences, that loosening the self-structure in a person whose attention is unsteady is the riskiest order. Steady attention first is the protective order. Learning that steadiness is the purpose of this stage.
  • It matches the Christian path. The Christian tradition’s own order is behavior first, then attention and watchfulness, then presence and love. Stages 2, 3, and 4 already follow it.

3.3 The spiral, not the ladder

It is tempting to read the order above as a ladder: climb one rung, leave it behind, climb the next. Do not read it that way. A ladder teaches you that the early practice is something to get past. That is a false understanding. The real shape is a spiral.

On a spiral, you come back around to the same place again and again, but each time you are somewhat deeper, and the view is different. You do not leave focused attention when you move on. You carry it with you, and you return to it at every depth. An experienced practitioner still begins most sittings by gathering attention on one simple thing. What changes is not the practice. What changes is the person doing it and what the practice does in them.

How a turn of the spiral works

  • First turn (this stage). The practice of focusing attention is something you do, deliberately and gently. It takes repetition and patience. Your attention drifts often, and you return often. You are building the capacity.
  • Later turns. You come back to the same practice, and it works on you differently. That is not something to look for or measure. It arrives as a consequence of continuing faithfully, and the way to meet it is the same as always: return.
  • Every turn begins at the beginning. On a bad day or in a hard season you will find yourself back at the first turn. That is not failure. It is how spirals work.

Choosing a practice

You will find seven practices below. Each is used to train your attention, and each has different strengths and weaknesses. You will choose one. Here is how it works. Read all seven descriptions. Answer the criteria in Part 4.2, and the app will show you a shortlist of two or three. Then sample freely: try any of the seven, in any order. Sampling sessions do not count toward your progress to Stage 5. The sampling period ends when you have decided on a practice or after 28 days, whichever comes first. When one feels like yours, tap “This is my practice” in the app. After that, stay with it. A practice you keep switching cannot deepen. Talk with your mentor before you change. It affects how your progress is counted.

A practice that is wrong for you will not deepen, and a practice that is right for you will not stop being right just because a new stage begins. There is a real danger here, and you should know about it. If you can change practice any time, the easiest way to avoid the hard part of practice is to change practice. Almost every serious student meets a stretch when the practice itself feels like a wall. That is the moment people go shopping. So here is the guidance:

  • If you want to change because the practice feels difficult, stay. Difficulty is part of the training. Returning again and again is how you train.
  • If you want to change because the practice is wrong for you (it keeps making you more anxious, it keeps leaving you numb, or you cannot do it in your actual life), that is wisdom, not avoidance.
  • You will not always be able to tell which one it is. That is what your mentor is for. If you are in doubt about changing, talk with your mentor.

Talk with your mentor before you change. It affects how your progress is counted.

3.4 Why some traditional practices work less well than they could

Not every focusing practice does the same job equally well. Here is the reason, and it follows from the science described in Part 2.

Focused attention works by turning up the volume on one simple present thing so the story-making parts of the brain get less to work with. That means the best anchor is one that gives the storyteller as little to hold onto as possible. Call this the meaning weight of a practice: how much meaning, story, memory, emotion, and association the object carries.

In this table, we present some commonly used practices for focusing your awareness. (You will learn more about these practices in Part 4 below.) This table is provided to help you see how these different practices work.

Practice Focus

Meaning weight

Why

The visual stimulus of a circle

Lowest

A plain shape. It means almost nothing, so there is little to think about. While you can read into the practice (unity, wholeness, etc.) that meaning is clearly coming from you and has nothing to do with the actual image.

The kinesthetic stimulus of breathing

Low

Pure sensation, happening now, with no story attached.

The kinesthetic stimulus of walking

Low

Pure sensation, happening now, with no story attached.

Visual stimulus of a plain cross

Low to medium

Very simple in form but carries a lifetime of Christian meaning for many students.

Auditory stimulus of chant

Medium

The rhythm and sound hold attention well. The words, however, can add devotional content, which works to counter the purpose of this form of meditation.

Auditory stimulus of a single spoken word.

Medium to High, depending on the word you choose

Any word can be chosen, but many chosen words carry doctrine, memory, and feeling. This is its strength as devotion and its cost as an anchor.

The spoken words of the Jesus Prayer

Highest

Carries doctrine and feeling and leads to devotion. This lessens its utility as an anchor.

These ratings describe the usual form of each practice. A different word or line can make a practice lighter or heavier.

A practice with heavy meaning does two things at once. It gathers your attention, which is good. However, it also keeps the thinking and feeling parts of the mind busy, which is the very thing focused attention is trying to quiet. A student praying the Jesus Prayer, for example, may find the mind drifting into visualization, theology, or memory inside the prayer, and may never notice because it all feels devout.

This does not mean the heavy practices are worse. They work through a different channel: relationship and the heart. For a student whose faith is their mother tongue, they may be the most natural way in. They are often the practices that last a lifetime. The point is only that, for the specific job of this stage, the lighter anchors do the mechanical work of focusing your attention more cleanly, and the heavier ones ask more of you.

Because of the spiral, you do not have to choose once and forever. A practice that fits you now may not fit you later, and one that does not fit you now may fit you later. If your attention steadies and a different practice begins to feel like home, that is a change of fit. Talk with your mentor before you change. How you start is a matter of fit, not rank. The lighter practices are not the beginner’s practices, and the heavier ones are not the advanced ones. For many students, the heavier practices are where they stay for years.

3.5 Where the later practices fit

This stage teaches only the first kind of meditation, focused attention. But you should know that the others are coming, and why they belong where they do.

The stages after this one are called the absorptions. In them, attention becomes so steady that the usual running commentary falls quiet, then stops. Reactions begin to fade. Eventually the sense of a separate watcher begins to thin. The traditions are clear that these states arise from steady concentration. You do not manufacture them.

As that happens, the way you practice changes too. In Stage 5, practices that open attention, so that you watch whatever arises without grabbing it, begin to be developed. This is the second kind of meditation. It becomes natural once attention is steady, and it is risky before then. Much later, you will be introduced to practices for letting go of the watcher itself. They are not for now, and describing them in detail now would only give you something to chase.

For this stage, your job is simple. Learn to listen. Learn to return.

Part 4. Choosing and Practicing

4.1 Seven practices

Seven focused-attention practices are offered. All seven do the same job: gather attention on one thing, notice when it leaves, and return. They differ in the channel they use, whether eyes, body, voice, or heart, and in how much meaning they carry (Part 3.4). They are listed here from lightest to heaviest.

Full instructions for every practice are in your Stage 4 Practice Pages. What follows is a short introduction to each, enough to help you choose.

Every practice begins the same way: from the heart center you found in Stage 3. Before you open toward your anchor, bring your awareness into your heart and rest there for a moment. Then engage in your practice. The heart is where you start from. The anchor is what you return to.

Each practice begins as something you do, deliberately and gently. Practiced faithfully over many months, practices like these change in ways the traditions describe in their own words. Do not look for that change, and do not reach for it early. Reaching is itself a subtle form of forcing.

1. The visual stimulus of a circle

Meaning weight: Lowest.

What it is: A plain circle, drawn on a card or paper, the enso of our logo, or a ring of any kind, used as the one thing your eyes rest on. It is the most neutral visual anchor and fits students who come from outside the Christian tradition.

Best for: Students who gather attention most easily through the eyes, or who want a practice with no religious content at all.

Full instructions: Stage 4 Practice Pages, page 1.

2. The kinesthetic stimulus of breathing

Meaning weight: Low.

What it is: The natural breath, felt as the physical sensations of the rising and falling of your chest, with attention resting where the breath is felt at the heart center. This is not breath control or breathing exercises. You do not change the breath. You feel the breath that is already there.

Full instructions: Stage 4 Practice Pages, page 2.

3. The kinesthetic stimulus of walking

Meaning weight: Low.

What it is: Slow, deliberate walking with a focus on the physical sensations in the soles of your feet, and in the contraction and relaxation of the paired muscle groups in your legs. The pace is very slow so that you experience fully what is usually experienced as an automatic behavior. Walking suits restless students and people who sit poorly.

Best for: Students who are restless, students whose bodies rebel against sitting, and phone-first students who need a practice that can be done in short, real-life spaces.

Full instructions: Stage 4 Practice Pages, page 3.

4. The visual stimulus of a plain cross

Meaning weight: Low to medium.

What it is: A simple, unadorned cross, such as two pieces of wood or a drawing of two lines, used as the target for your eyes to rest on. It has little image content to interpret, but for many Christians it carries a great deal of meaning.

Best for: Students with a Christian formation who want a visual anchor with little content to interpret.

Full instructions: Stage 4 Practice Pages, page 4.

5. The auditory stimulus of chant

Meaning weight: Medium.

What it is: The slow repetition of one short line or syllable, sung or spoken softly on a steady note. The rhythm and the sound hold attention. Words are kept very short. An ancient Christian chant, often used in monasteries, is “Oh God, come to my assistance.” A frequently used Eastern chant is “Om” (which is pronounced as ‘ohm’, not as ‘A-U-M’).

Best for: Students who focus through sound, students who like communal and embodied prayer, and students who find silent sitting too empty.

Full instructions: Stage 4 Practice Pages, page 5.

6. The auditory stimulus of a single spoken word

Meaning weight: Medium to High, depending on the word you choose.

What it is: The repetition of a single word, slowly repeated, used as an anchor for attention. A single word, such as Now, Still, Lord, or One serves as your anchor.

Best for: Students who want a concrete anchor and can choose a plain word, or students whose faith language is their mother tongue and who accept the extra content a loaded word brings. Expect to meet more content here than in the lighter practices, and more with a loaded word than a plain one.

Full instructions: Stage 4 Practice Pages, page 6.

7. The spoken words of the Jesus Prayer

Meaning weight: Highest.

What it is: The repetition of a short phrase or sentence which serves as an anchor for your attention. You can use an attenuated form of the classic Jesus Prayer, “Lord Jesus Christ, have mercy on me.” The words themselves are not important for the goals of your practice. Their function, of returning your attention to the stimulus, is of great importance. For the goals of this stage, the words matter only as an anchor. Their meaning is what makes this practice a prayer as well.

Best for: Students whose faith is their mother tongue, students who need something concrete to return to, and students who love liturgical repetition. Because of its high meaning weight, expect to meet more content here than in the lighter practices.

Full instructions: Stage 4 Practice Pages, page 7.

Next: how to choose a practice, how to run a session, and how practice carries into the rest of your day.

Choosing, Practicing, and the Rest of the Day

Last session: why listening comes first, the spiral, and the seven practices. Today: how to choose one, how to run a session, and what the rest of your day and the gate to Stage 5 look like.